If you’re thinking about a new roof, the big question on your mind might be: “Is a metal roof cheaper than shingles?” It’s an important consideration, especially with so many roofing options available. Both shingle and metal roofs have pros and cons, and understanding the costs upfront and long-term can help you make a more informed decision. Whether it’s your first roof replacement or you’re upgrading, there’s more to choosing a roof than just the initial price.
In this blog, we’ll compare the two most common roof types: asphalt shingle roofs and metal roofs. We’ll walk through the costs, durability, maintenance, and even appearance to help you see how each performs over time. While asphalt shingles might seem cheaper upfront, metal roofing offers long-term value that makes it the smarter investment for most homeowners. Let’s dive in and compare the costs of both types of roofing.
Initial Costs of Shingle and Metal Roofs
Material costs and installation prices will heavily influence your decision when deciding on a new roof. The average cost of a roof replacement varies based on the size of your home and the type of roofing you choose. Both asphalt roofs and metal roofs have different initial price points, so let’s break them down.
Asphalt Shingle Roof: Initial Costs
The most common roofing material in the U.S. is the asphalt shingle roof. Shingles cost around $6 to $10 per square foot installed, which makes them the go-to choice for homeowners on a budget. Labor costs for shingles are typically lower because asphalt roofs are easier to install and most contractors are experienced in shingle installation.
However, the initial savings can come with trade-offs. Shingle roofs last about 15 to 25 years, depending on the climate and quality of materials. In some cases, poor installation can shorten the lifespan, leading to unexpected repair costs or early replacement.
Metal Roof: Initial Costs
The cost of a metal roof is higher than shingles upfront. Depending on the type of metal—such as aluminum, steel, or standing seam metal roof—you can expect to pay between $10 to $20 per square foot installed. While material costs are higher for metal, it’s essential to consider that the investment upfront pays off over time.
Labor costs for metal roofing can also be higher since installation takes more time and requires specialized skills. However, the durability and energy efficiency of metal roofing makes it a smart investment for homeowners looking to avoid multiple replacements over their home’s lifetime.
Long-Term Costs of Shingle and Metal Roofs
When thinking about roofing, it’s not just the initial price that matters—it’s also the long-term costs. Some roofs may be cheap to install but expensive to maintain or replace over time.
Long-Term Costs of Asphalt Shingles
While asphalt shingles have lower upfront costs, they don’t last as long as metal roofs. A typical shingle roof will need to be replaced every 20 to 30 years, sometimes even sooner if the roof suffers damage from wind, rain, or snow. Over a 50-year period, that could mean two or even three replacements, which adds up in both materials and labor.
Shingle roofs also absorb heat, which can drive up energy bills, especially during the summer months. They provide less energy efficiency, leading to higher cooling costs over time.
Long-Term Costs of Metal Roofs
A metal roof is designed to last 50 to 70 years, and some roofs can even exceed 100 years with proper care. This means that while you might pay more upfront, you won’t need to worry about roof replacement for a very long time. In fact, installing a metal roof could be the last roof you ever buy.
In addition to longevity, metal roofs offer excellent energy efficiency. They reflect heat rather than absorbing it, keeping homes cooler and helping to reduce energy bills. Over time, the savings on cooling costs can offset the higher initial metal roof costs.
Durability of Shingle and Metal Roofs
Durability is a significant factor when comparing roofing materials. After all, no one wants to deal with frequent repairs or premature replacements. While they don’t directly affect the cost of installation, they are an important consideration when you take the financial aspects of a new roof into the equation.
Asphalt Shingle Roof Durability
Asphalt shingles can handle most weather conditions, but they aren’t as tough as metal. Hail, high winds, and heavy snow can cause damage over time. In colder climates, shingles may become brittle, increasing the chances of cracking.
Shingle roofs are prone to algae and moss growth, which can shorten their lifespan if not treated regularly. Homeowners in areas with extreme weather might find that shingle roofs require frequent repairs, adding to their total cost over time.
Metal Roof Durability
Metal roofs are incredibly durable and can withstand extreme weather conditions, including heavy snow, hailstorms, and strong winds. They are resistant to fire and won’t rot or warp over time. Unlike shingles, metal roofing doesn’t attract algae or moss, making it an ideal choice for homeowners looking for a low-maintenance solution.
Depending on the type of metal, your roof could last 70 years or more, withstanding anything Mother Nature throws its way.
Maintenance of Shingle and Metal Roofs
Maintenance is another key factor to consider when choosing between shingles and metal roofing. Let’s look at what’s involved in keeping each type of roof in good shape.
Maintenance of Asphalt Roofs
Shingle roofs require regular maintenance. This includes cleaning moss and algae off the roof, checking for cracked or missing shingles, and sealing leaks as they appear. Failure to maintain a shingle roof can shorten its lifespan significantly, leading to costly repairs.
Maintenance of Metal Roofs
Metal roofs require minimal maintenance. They don’t crack or warp, and they resist moss growth. Most homeowners only need to inspect the roof annually and ensure that fasteners remain tight. If scratches or dents occur, simple touch-ups will keep the roof in excellent condition.
Appearance and Curb Appeal
While appearance doesn’t directly impact cost, it plays a role in home value. Asphalt roofs come in a variety of colors and designs, giving homeowners some flexibility. However, they tend to look more traditional and wear down over time.
Metal roofs, on the other hand, offer a sleek and modern appearance. Homeowners can choose from several roof types, including standing seam metal roofs, metal shingles, and even copper roofing. A metal roof can improve curb appeal and boost resale value, making it a worthy investment.
Other Costs to Consider
When weighing your roofing options, it’s important to look beyond the installation price. Metal roofs often have lower insurance premiums because of their fire resistance. Many also come with warranties lasting 30 to 50 years or more, compared to shorter warranties on shingles.
Repairs are another factor. While both types of roofs may need occasional repairs, metal roofs tend to have fewer issues over time. Additionally, some homeowners may qualify for tax credits or energy rebates when installing energy-efficient metal roofs.
Why Metal Roofing Is the Smarter Choice
While asphalt shingles may seem cheaper at first, the long-term costs add up quickly with frequent replacements and higher energy bills. In contrast, metal roofs offer durability, energy efficiency, and minimal maintenance, making them a cost-effective choice over time. Replacing an asphalt shingle roof even once can offset the initial metal roof costs, especially since metal roofs can last 70 years or more.
If you’re looking for a roofing solution that provides lasting value, metal roofing is the way to go.
FAQs When Comparing Asphalt and Metal Roofing
How much does a metal roof cost compared to shingles?
Metal roofs cost more upfront, ranging from $15 to $22 per square foot, while shingles are around $6 to $10 per square foot.
How long do metal roofs last?
Metal roofs can last 50 to 70 years or more with proper care while asphalt roofs are usually good for 20-25 years.
Are metal roofs energy-efficient?
Yes, metal roofs reflect heat, reducing energy bills and keeping homes cooler. Asphalt roofing also has some reflective properties depending on the style and manufacturer.
Do shingles require more maintenance?
Yes, shingle roofs need regular maintenance to prevent moss, leaks, and cracks. Metal roofing usually just needs to be hosed down a couple of times a year.
Can metal roofs withstand extreme weather?
Yes, metal roofs are highly durable and can handle heavy snow, hail, and strong winds up to 165 mph!
Are metal roofs louder than shingles?
With proper insulation, metal roofs are not significantly louder during rain–some folks even like the sound of rain on their metal roofing.
Do metal roofs increase home value?
Yes, metal roofs can improve curb appeal and boost resale value. Mountaintop Metal Roofing’s transferable lifetime warranty is also a nice selling point.
How do I get a quote for a metal roof?
Contact Mountaintop Metal Roofing for a free consultation and quote today!
Ready to upgrade your roof? Reach out to Mountaintop Metal Roofing today to learn more about our metal roofing solutions and schedule your free consultation.